Education, Science, Technology, Innovation and Life
Open Access
Sign In

The Boundaries of Consent and the Resilience of Norms: An International Law Analysis of Japan's Withdrawal from the International Whaling Regulatory Regime

Download as PDF

DOI: 10.23977/law.2026.050218 | Downloads: 4 | Views: 101

Author(s)

Sun Zitong 1

Affiliation(s)

1 Institute of Law, Dalian Maritime University, Dalian, China

Corresponding Author

Sun Zitong

ABSTRACT

Japan's 2019 withdrawal from the International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling and its subsequent resumption of commercial whaling are often cited as evidence of the diminishing binding force of international law. This article contends that such a conclusion is unduly reductionist. By examining the structural deficiencies inherent in the consent-based international legal order, particularly the principle of state consent and institutional fragmentation, while simultaneously assessing the continuing influence of international law through judicial interpretation, normative evolution, and the shaping of behavioural expectations, this article reveals the dual character of international environmental law. That dual character consists of its vulnerability when confronted with conflicting national interests and its normative resilience. The article further argues that the effectiveness of international law should not be measured solely by its capacity to compel compliance, but rather by its ability to foster cross-cultural consensus. A genuinely robust international legal order is not one that imposes uniform standards through coercive power, but one that reconciles respect for cultural diversity and divergent national interests with a minimum consensus on core ecological values. Only by combining institutional efficacy with normative legitimacy can international environmental law provide enduring protection for marine biodiversity and respond effectively to future global environmental challenges.

KEYWORDS

International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling; State Consent; Treaty Withdrawal; Normative Resilience; International Environmental Law; Institutional Fragmentation; Marine Biodiversity Conservation, Japan

CITE THIS PAPER

Sun Zitong. The Boundaries of Consent and the Resilience of Norms: An International Law Analysis of Japan's Withdrawal from the International Whaling Regulatory Regime. Science of Law Journal (2026). Vol. 5, No. 2, 126-131. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/DOI: 10.23977/law.2026.050218.

REFERENCES

[1] Tomasz Kamiński and Karol Karski (eds), 40 Years of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea: Assessment and Prospects (Routledge 2025), 193–205.
[2] Chie Kojima, Japan's Decision to Withdraw from the International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling, Asia-Pacific Journal of Ocean Law and Policy, 2019, Vol. 4, No. (1),93–96.
[3] David Caron, The International Whaling Commission and the North Atlantic Marine Mammal Commission: The Institutional Risks of Coercion in Consensual Structures, American Journal of International Law, 1995, Vol. 89, No. (1),154–174.
[4] Lotta Viikari, International Whaling Commission as a Natural Resource Management Regime: Quest for Balance Between Western Science, State Governance and Indigenous Self-Determination. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights, 2023, Vol. 30, No. (2), 274–300.
[5] Amy Catalinac and Gerald Chan, Japan, the West, and the Whaling Issue: Understanding the Japanese Side. Japan Forum, 2005, Vol. 17, No.(1), 133–163.
[6] Michal Kolmaš, International Pressure and Japanese Withdrawal from the International Whaling Commission: When Shaming Fails. Australian Journal of International Affairs, 2021, Vol. 75, No.(2), 197–216.
[7] Jennifer L Bailey, Arrested Development: The Fight to End Commercial Whaling as a Case of Failed Norm Change. European Journal of International Relations, 2008, Vol. 14, No. (2), 289–318.

All published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Copyright © 2016 - 2031 Clausius Scientific Press Inc. All Rights Reserved.